Guys lets let up on Amy ok? Yes things haven't gone perfectly. But remember that Tkay was in a very similar situation when she got Jenna?
People make mistakes. People also do their own thing regardless of advice.
One of the original thoughts in this thread was that. But Amy is learning about hers, she has been honest about it. That's not worth punishing her over.
Honesty is really what matters. People can learn about their dogs as they go, if they not afraid to ask the silly things that worry them. People have human babies when they are really young and know nothing, and it doesn't necessarily mean that they don't find their way and make great parents.
Life is a journey, we all learn along the way. It's human nature to be selective in what advice we follow, and all too often not follow advice, but learn the hard way ourselves.